Inspector’s narrative
What the inspector wrote
Section 483.12 Freedom from Abuse, Neglect, and Exploitation - The resident has the
right to be free from abuse, neglect, misappropriation of resident property, and
exploitation as defined in this subpart. This includes but is not limited to freedom
from corporal punishment, involuntary seclusion and any physical or chemical
restraint not required to treat the resident's medical symptoms.
(a) The facility must -
(1) Not use verbal, mental, sexual, or physical abuse, corporal punishment, or
involuntary seclusion.
The following citation is written as a result of an unannounced visit conducted at
the facility on 10/19/21 at 9:03 a.m. to investigate facility reported incident
CA0075681.
The Department determined the facility failed to ensure Resident 1 was free from
abuse, when Resident 1 was restrained while Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs)
provided care and sustained discoloration on bilateral forearms.
Resident 1 was admitted to the facility on 1/2/20 and diagnoses included chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD-chronic inflammatory lung disease that
makes it hard to breath) and psychosis (mental disorder characterized by
disconnection from reality).
Review of Resident l's Quarterly MDS (Minimum Data Set-an assessment tool),
dated 9/3/21 described Resident A as able to make herself understood and as
having the ability to understand others. The MDS described Resident 1 as having a
BIMS (a brief screening that aids in detecting cognitive impairment) score 13
which indicated she was cognitively intact and as having no delirium or behavioral
symptoms.
Review of Resident l's SBAR (incident reporting tool) -Alleged Abuse Report of
Incident," dated 10/12/21 indicated Resident 1 called 911 and stated "she was
abused by staff member, resident states t6hat (sic) she was held down by certain
CNA ... " The SBAR indicated Resident 1 was interviewed by a nurse and the
Social Service Director (SSD). Resident 1 stated, "she was held down by CNA
and it hurt her arm." The document also indicated under Social Services Note:
"Resident [1] expressed fear and anxiety regarding CNA providing continued
care."
Review of Resident 1 's, "Skin Inspection Assessment-V3," dated 12/12/21
indicated "Full head to toe done, only issues noted were discoloration on bilateral
forearms."
Review of a facility form, "Interview/Investigative Record," dated 10/11/21,
indicated CNA 1 went back into Resident l's room to help change her due to
Resident 1 "is supposed to be 2 people assist." "CNA [CNA 1] asked for
permission to help change resident, resident stated no, CNA [CNA l] proceeded to
help B/C (because) she felt the other CNA needed help. Patient [Resident 1]
scratched CNA, held residents' hands down, pt (patient) kicked her & called her a
bitch, she proceeded to spit. CNA 1 then threw a towel on her face to protect self
until care was complete."
Review of a facility form "Interview/Investigative Record," dated 10/12/21
indicated CNA 2 was interviewed. CNA 2 stated Resident 1, "Didn't want to be
change; linen soiled transfer bed to w/c (wheelchair) to clean bed; PT (patient) kept
pulling off brief. Spit on [CNA 1]; kick [CNA l]; cussed at [LN l]. Held
arm/hand shut to keep resident "safe." She did not see towel on mouth or hands
held down. Asked [CNA l] how she protected herself from spit, [CNA l] said she
put towel." CNA 2 was asked if she reported to supervisor she replied, "No."
Review of CNA l's "Disciplinary Action Notice," dated 10/18/21 indicated CNA
1 failed "to provide resident care consistent with respect for patient's right to
refuse." The notice also indicated CNA 1 failed "to provide care consistent with
facility policy and procedure with respect to residents right to refuse as evidenced
by restraining patient to provide care, patient refusing care." "Summary of
disciplinary action to be taken ... allegation of abuse has been substantiated."
"Consequence of failure to abide by policy: termination."
Review of CNA 2's, "Disciplinary Action Notice," dated 10/18/21 indicated CNA
2 failed "to provide resident care consistent with respect for patients right to
refuse." The notice indicated, "Allegation of abuse has been substantiated."
"Consequence of failure to abide by policy: termination."
Review of the facility's policy, "Abuse Prevention, Intervention, Investigation &
Crime Reporting Policy," revised November 2016 indicated, "The resident has the
right to be free from abuse ... This includes but is not limited to freedom from
corporal punishment, involuntary seclusion and any physical or chemical restraint
not required to treat the resident's medial symptoms. The facility is responsible for
assuring resident safety by prohibiting verbal, mental, sexual, or physical abuse,
corporal punishment, or involuntary seclusion; and ensuring that residents are free
from physical or chemical restrains imposed for purpose of discipline or
convenience and that are not required to treat the resident's medical symptoms."
In violation of the above cited standards, the facility failed to ensure the resident
was free from abuse, neglect, misappropriation of resident property, and
exploitation as defined in this subpart. This includes but is not limited to freedom
from corporal punishment, involuntary seclusion and any physical or chemical
restraint not required to treat the resident's medical symptoms, including but not
limited to: The Department determined the facility failed to ensure Resident 1 was
free from abuse, when Resident 1 was restrained while Certified Nursing
Assistants (CNAs) provided care and sustained discoloration on bilateral forearms.
This violation caused or occurred under circumstances likely to cause significant
humiliation, indignity, anxiety, or other emotional trauma to a patient.