F 0727
Level of Harm - Minimal harm
or potential for actual harm
Residents Affected - Many
Have a registered nurse on duty 8 hours a day; and select a registered nurse to be the director of nurses on
a full time basis.
Based on record review and interview the facility failed to maintain the services of a registered nurse (RN)
for at least eight (8) consecutive hours a day, seven (7) days per week. This had the potential to affect all 40
residents residing in the facility.
Findings include:
Review of the staffing schedule from 10/01/19 through 10/28/19 revealed there was no RN coverage for at
least eight consecutive hours on 10/12/19, 10/13/19, 10/26/19 or 10/27/19.
On 10/30/19 at 4:00 P.M., interview with RN #400 verified the above finding.
This deficiency substantiates Complaint Number OH00107669.
Any deficiency statement ending with an asterisk (*) denotes a deficiency which the institution may be excused from correcting providing it is determined that other
safeguards provide sufficient protection to the patients. (See instructions.) Except for nursing homes, the findings stated above are disclosable 90 days following the
date of survey whether or not a plan of correction is provided. For nursing homes, the above findings and plans of correction are disclosable 14 days following the date
these documents are made available to the facility. If deficiencies are cited, an approved plan of correction is requisite to continued program participation.
LABORATORY DIRECTOR'S OR PROVIDER/SUPPLIER
REPRESENTATIVE'S SIGNATURE
TITLE
(X6) DATE
FORM CMS-2567 (02/99)
Previous Versions Obsolete
Facility ID:
If continuation sheet
Page 1 of 4
Event ID:
365580
Printed: 05/15/2026
Form Approved OMB
No. 0938-0391
Department of Health & Human Services
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
STATEMENT OF DEFICIENCIES
AND PLAN OF CORRECTION
(X1) PROVIDER/SUPPLIER/CLIA
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER:
(X2) MULTIPLE CONSTRUCTION
365580
B. Wing
A. Building
(X3) DATE SURVEY
COMPLETED
10/31/2019
NAME OF PROVIDER OR SUPPLIER
STREET ADDRESS, CITY, STATE, ZIP CODE
Shepherd of the Valley-Boardman
7148 West Blvd
Youngstown, OH 44512
For information on the nursing home's plan to correct this deficiency, please contact the nursing home or the state survey agency.
(X4) ID PREFIX TAG
SUMMARY STATEMENT OF DEFICIENCIES
(Each deficiency must be preceded by full regulatory or LSC identifying information)
F 0881
Implement a program that monitors antibiotic use.
Level of Harm - Minimal harm
or potential for actual harm
**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** Based on
record review and interview the facility failed to implement an effective antibiotic (ATB) stewardship program
to ensure the proper use of antibiotics. This affected two residents (#31 and #12) residents residing in the
facility.
Residents Affected - Few
Findings include:
1. Resident #31 was admitted to the facility on [DATE] with a diagnosis which included pancreatic cancer.
Review of a nursing note, dated 07/23/19 revealed the resident did not have any signs and/or symptoms
(s/s) of a urinary tract infection (UTI). Further review revealed the Hospice nurse recommended a
urinalysis.
Review of the physician's orders, dated 07/25/19 revealed an order to obtain a urinalysis. Review of the
urinalysis results received 07/29/19 revealed the resident had one organism present.
Review of the physician's orders, dated 07/29/19 revealed an order to start an ATB, Ampicillin 500
milligrams (mg) three times a day (TID) for seven days, for a urinary tract infection. Further review of the
medication administrator record (MAR) from 07/29/19 through 08/05/19 revealed the resident received the
ATB as ordered.
Review of the July 2019 ATB stewardship monthly log revealed there was no indication the resident was on
an ATB. Further review revealed there was no McGreer Constitutional Criteria Protocol (MCCP) or ATB use
tool completed for the resident.
Review of the August 2019 ATB log revealed the resident had a UTI which an ATB was given but the
McGreer criteria was not met indicating an ATB was not warranted. There was no evidence of notifying the
physician.
Review of the nursing notes dated 08/23/19 through 08/26/19 revealed the resident did not have any s/s of
an UTI. Further review of the 08/26/19 note indicated the Hospice nurse requested an urinalysis.
Review of the nursing note dated 08/29/19 revealed the physician was contacted, ordered ATB and
requested the cultures be sent to him when available.
Review of the physician's order dated 08/29/19 revealed to start an ATB, Keflex 500 mg three times per day
for seven days for UTI. Further review of the MAR revealed the resident received the ATB as ordered.
Review of the urinalysis received 08/31/19 revealed the resident had one organism. The report indicated
which ATB were effective (sensitivity) in treating the infection and Keflex was not listed. Further review of
the handwritten note on the report revealed the resident was to receive the ATB but did not have any s/s of
UTI, it was signed and dated 09/03/19.
On 10/30/19 at 4:55 P.M., interview with Registered Nurse (RN) #400 revealed the facility used the
(continued on next page)
FORM CMS-2567 (02/99)
Previous Versions Obsolete
Event ID:
Facility ID:
365580
If continuation sheet
Page 2 of 4
Printed: 05/15/2026
Form Approved OMB
No. 0938-0391
Department of Health & Human Services
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
STATEMENT OF DEFICIENCIES
AND PLAN OF CORRECTION
(X1) PROVIDER/SUPPLIER/CLIA
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER:
(X2) MULTIPLE CONSTRUCTION
365580
B. Wing
A. Building
(X3) DATE SURVEY
COMPLETED
10/31/2019
NAME OF PROVIDER OR SUPPLIER
STREET ADDRESS, CITY, STATE, ZIP CODE
Shepherd of the Valley-Boardman
7148 West Blvd
Youngstown, OH 44512
For information on the nursing home's plan to correct this deficiency, please contact the nursing home or the state survey agency.
(X4) ID PREFIX TAG
SUMMARY STATEMENT OF DEFICIENCIES
(Each deficiency must be preceded by full regulatory or LSC identifying information)
F 0881
Level of Harm - Minimal harm
or potential for actual harm
Residents Affected - Few
McGreer protocol for the use of ATBs. RN #400 stated when a resident presented with s/s of a possible
infection, the physician was notified. If the physician wanted to order an ATB the nurse talking to the
physician was supposed to complete the MCCP and if the criteria was not met, indicating an ATB was not
warranted, the physician was to be informed. After completing the MCCP the nurse was to put the
assessment in RN #400's mailbox for her to review. She stated it could take up to three days to review. RN
#400 stated she would then complete an ATB use tool to ensure the ATB stewardship program was being
implemented and was effective. If the physician was not willing to follow the protocol she would attempt to
talk to the physician about the requirements. RN #400 verified the MCCP assessments were not being
completed when ATBs were being ordered. RN #400 verified residents were receiving ATBs when the
McGreer criteria was not met. RN #400 verified there was no evidence the Resident #31 was receiving the
ATB in July 2019. RN #400 verified Resident #31 had a positive urinalysis but did not have s/s therefore did
not meet the McGreer's criteria for receiving ATBs but the ATB was ordered and there was no evidence the
physician was questioned about the use of the ATB.
2. Resident #12 was admitted to the facility on [DATE] with a diagnosis which included heart disease.
Review of the nursing notes, dated 08/23/19 through 08/27/19 revealed there was no evidence of s/s of an
UTI.
Review of the urinalysis collected 08/27/19 and received 09/03/19 revealed a handwritten note stating the
UTI was uncomplicated and start ATB.
Review of the physician's orders dated 09/03/19 revealed to start an ATB, Levaquin 250 mg at night for
three nights for UTI. Further review of the MAR revealed the ATB was given as ordered.
Review of the ATB use tool revealed the resident did not met the MCCP criteria for the use of the ATB.
Review of the MCCP dated 09/03/19 revealed it did not indicate specifically how and if the resident met the
criteria for the use of the ATB.
On 10/30/19 at 4:55 P.M., interview with Registered Nurse (RN) #400 revealed the facility used the
McGreer protocol for the use of ATBs. RN #400 stated when a resident presented with s/s of a possible
infection, the physician was notified. If the physician wanted to order an ATB the nurse talking to the
physician was supposed to complete the MCCP and if the criteria was not met, indicating an ATB was not
warranted, the physician was to be informed. After completing the MCCP the nurse was to put the
assessment in RN #400's mailbox for her to review. She stated it could take up to three days to review. RN
#400 stated she would then complete an ATB use tool to ensure the ATB stewardship program was being
implemented and was effective. If the physician was not willing to follow the protocol she would attempt to
talk to the physician about the requirements. RN #400 verified the MCCP assessments were not being
completed when ATBs were being ordered. RN #400 verified residents were receiving ATBs when the
McGreer criteria was not met.
Review of the ATB stewardship policy, revised 10/01/17, revealed it was to promote the appropriate use of
antibiotics and a system of monitoring to improve resident outcomes and reduce ATB resistance. ATB
would be prescribed for the correct indication, dose and duration to appropriately treat the resident while
attempting to reduce the development of ATB-resistant organisms or other adverse consequences or
outcomes. When the nurse suspected the resident had an infection, the nurse would perform
(continued on next page)
FORM CMS-2567 (02/99)
Previous Versions Obsolete
Event ID:
Facility ID:
365580
If continuation sheet
Page 3 of 4
Printed: 05/15/2026
Form Approved OMB
No. 0938-0391
Department of Health & Human Services
Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
STATEMENT OF DEFICIENCIES
AND PLAN OF CORRECTION
(X1) PROVIDER/SUPPLIER/CLIA
IDENTIFICATION NUMBER:
(X2) MULTIPLE CONSTRUCTION
365580
B. Wing
A. Building
(X3) DATE SURVEY
COMPLETED
10/31/2019
NAME OF PROVIDER OR SUPPLIER
STREET ADDRESS, CITY, STATE, ZIP CODE
Shepherd of the Valley-Boardman
7148 West Blvd
Youngstown, OH 44512
For information on the nursing home's plan to correct this deficiency, please contact the nursing home or the state survey agency.
(X4) ID PREFIX TAG
SUMMARY STATEMENT OF DEFICIENCIES
(Each deficiency must be preceded by full regulatory or LSC identifying information)
F 0881
Level of Harm - Minimal harm
or potential for actual harm
Residents Affected - Few
FORM CMS-2567 (02/99)
Previous Versions Obsolete
an evaluation of the resident while utilizing the MCCP to determine if any ATB was necessary or if a change
in therapy could be needed. Notify the physician of the change of condition and the evaluation information.
The nurse would monitor for results of any ordered diagnostics and notify the physician of the results to
ensure the resident was taking the appropriate ATB or if ATB needs to be discontinued or changed. If
indicated, based on the criteria, an ATB would be ordered, the physician would identify the diagnosis, the
appropriate ATB, proper dose, duration and route. In the event the physician ordered an ATB without
identification of the infection criteria, the physician would be requested to identify rationale for ordered ATB.
The medical director would be contacted for further direction. If the resident was admitted to the facility an
ATB ordered, the nurse would identify the indication for the use, documentation for dose, route, duration,
effectiveness and potential adverse consequences. The infection preventions would track ATB use an
monitor adherence to evidence-based criteria. During the monthly quality improvement committee meeting
ATB use would be analyzed and any potential action plans related to the analysis of the tracking and
trending would be implemented.
Event ID:
Facility ID:
365580
If continuation sheet
Page 4 of 4