366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0607
Develop and implement policies and procedures to prevent abuse, neglect, and theft.
Level of Harm - Minimal harm or potential for actual harm
**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** Based on record review, interview, and facility policy review the facility failed to implement their abuse policy regarding an allegation of potential staff-to-resident abuse for Resident #77. This affected one resident (#77) of seven residents reviewed for abuse. The facility census was 97.
Residents Affected - Few
Findings include: Review of the medical record for Resident #77 revealed an admission date of 04/07/23 with diagnoses including Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) a progressive neurodegenerative disease that affects nerve cells in the brain and spinal cord, arthritis, depression, and hypertension. Review of the quarterly Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #77 was cognitively intact. She required set up help for eating, oral hygiene, and personal hygiene, substantial or maximum assistance for showing or bathing, and was dependent on staff for toileting. Interview on 02/06/24 at 11:35 A.M. with Resident #77 revealed State Tested Nurse's Aide (STNA) #203 had been rough with her twice on 01/30/24. She revealed STNA #203 attempted to move the Hoyer pad (universal full body lift sling, used for bed positioning bathing assistance and transfers for disabled or dependent residents) from underneath her, causing her left arm to be pulled along with the pad. She reported her arm still hurt as a result. She revealed she told the nurse of the incident. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:40 P.M. with STNA #202 revealed she worked with Resident #77 on 01/30/24. She revealed Resident #77 told her she did not want STNA #203 to give her a shower because she was rough with her. STNA #202 revealed she told Registered Nurse (RN) #206 about Resident #77's concerns. STNA #202 revealed many residents told her STNA #203 was rough with care. STNA #202 revealed she overheard Resident #77 tell STNA #203 she was hurting her during her shower on 01/30/24. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:49 P.M. with STNA #203 revealed Resident #77 did not report any concerns to her regarding the care or services she provided on 01/30/24. Interview on 02/06/24 at 2:34 P.M. with RN #205 revealed she received a call from Resident #77's friend on 01/31/24 in which the resident's friend told her Resident #77 said her arm was caught underneath her and rolled behind her during care the prior day. RN #205 revealed she spoke to Resident #77 but did not specifically ask her about this incident. Interview on 02/07/24 at 8:56 A.M. with the Administrator revealed the facility was aware of Resident #77's friends' concern regarding potentially rough care for the resident on 01/30/24, but there was no investigation completed of the concern.
Page 1 of 9
366113
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0607
Level of Harm - Minimal harm or potential for actual harm
Residents Affected - Few
Review of the facility policy titled Resident Abuse Prevention Practices dated October 2022 revealed the facilities' policy was to protect all residents from mistreatment, neglect, and abuse. This included protecting residents from any situation that would be harmful. Alleged suspected or observed abuse, neglect, and mistreatment of a resident would be thoroughly investigated by the Administrator and the Director of Nursing (DON). The investigation would begin immediately after receiving the complaint. The resident would be examined for injury at the time of the complaint and appropriate medical attention given as necessary. Witness statements would be taken, and interviews conducted with anyone involved or witnessing the incident. Staff would immediately report the suspicion of or witnessed incident that may be abuse to the facility Administrator and/or designee. This deficiency represents noncompliance investigated under Complaint Number OH00150765.
366113
Page 2 of 9
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0609
Level of Harm - Minimal harm or potential for actual harm
Residents Affected - Few
Timely report suspected abuse, neglect, or theft and report the results of the investigation to proper authorities. **NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** Based on record review, interview, and facility policy review the facility failed to report an allegation of staff-to-resident abuse to the state agency as required. This affected one resident (#77) of seven residents reviewed for abuse. The facility census was 97.
Findings include: Review of the medical record for Resident #77 revealed an admission date of 04/07/23. Diagnoses included Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) a progressive neurodegenerative disease that affects nerve cells in the brain and spinal cord, arthritis, depression, and hypertension. Review of the quarterly Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #77 was cognitively intact. She required set up help for eating, oral hygiene, and personal hygiene, substantial or maximum assistance for showing or bathing, and was dependent on staff for toileting. Interview on 02/06/24 at 11:35 A.M. with Resident #77 revealed State Tested Nurse's Aide (STNA) #203 was rough with her twice on 01/30/234. She revealed STNA #203 attempted to move the Hoyer pad (universal full body lift sling, used for bed positioning bathing assistance and transfers for disabled or dependent residents) from underneath her, causing her left arm to be pulled along with the pad. She reported her arm still hurt as a result. She revealed she told the nurse of the incident. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:40 P.M. with STNA #202 revealed she worked with Resident #77 on 01/30/23. She revealed Resident #77 told her she did not want STNA #203 to give her a shower because she was rough with her. STNA #202 revealed she told Registered Nurse (RN) #206 about Resident #77's concerns. STNA #202 revealed many residents told her STNA #203 was rough with care. STNA #202 revealed she overheard Resident #77 tell STNA #203 she was hurting her during her shower on 01/30/24. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:49 P.M. with STNA #203 revealed Resident #77 did not report any concerns to her regarding the care or services she provided on 01/30/24. Interview on 02/06/24 at 2:34 P.M. with RN #205 revealed she received a call from Resident #77's friend on 01/31/24 in which the resident's friend told her Resident #77 said her arm was caught underneath her and rolled behind her during care prior day. RN #205 revealed she spoke to Resident #77 but did not specifically ask her about this incident. Interview on 02/07/24 at 8:56 A.M. with the Administrator revealed the facility was aware of Resident #77's friends' concern regarding potentially rough care for the resident on 01/30/24, but there was no self-reported incident to the state agency or investigation completed regarding the concern. Review of the facility policy titled Resident Abuse Prevention Practices dated October 2022 revealed the facilities' policy was to protect all residents from mistreatment, neglect, and abuse. This included protecting residents from any situation that would be harmful. Staff would immediately report the suspicion of or witnessed incident that may be abuse to the facility Administrator and/or designee and alleged or suspected violations would be reported to the Ohio Department of Health immediately.
366113
Page 3 of 9
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0609
This deficiency represents noncompliance investigated under Complaint Number OH00150765.
Level of Harm - Minimal harm or potential for actual harm
Residents Affected - Few
366113
Page 4 of 9
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0610
Respond appropriately to all alleged violations.
Level of Harm - Minimal harm or potential for actual harm
**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** Based on record review, interview, and facility policy review the facility failed to investigate an allegation of staff-to-resident abuse as required. This affected one resident (#77) of seven residents reviewed for abuse. The facility census was 97.
Residents Affected - Few
Findings include: Review of the medical record for Resident #77 revealed an admission date of 04/07/23. Diagnoses included Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) a progressive neurodegenerative disease that affects nerve cells in the brain and spinal cord, arthritis, depression, and hypertension. Review of the quarterly Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #77 was cognitively intact. She required set up help for eating, oral hygiene, and personal hygiene, substantial or maximum assistance for showing or bathing, and was dependent on staff for toileting. Interview on 02/06/24 at 11:35 A.M. with Resident #77 revealed State Tested Nurse's Aide (STNA) #203 was rough with her twice on 01/30/234. She revealed STNA #203 attempted to move the Hoyer pad (universal full body lift sling, used for bed positioning bathing assistance and transfers for disabled or dependent residents) from underneath her, causing her left arm to be pulled along with the pad. She reported her arm still hurt as a result. She revealed she told the nurse of the incident. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:40 P.M. with STNA #202 revealed she worked with Resident #77 on 01/30/23. She revealed Resident #77 told her she did not want STNA #203 to give her a shower because she was rough with her. STNA #202 revealed she told Registered Nurse (RN) #206 about Resident #77's concerns. STNA #202 revealed many residents told her STNA #203 was rough with care. STNA #202 revealed she overheard Resident #77 tell STNA #203 she was hurting her during her shower on 01/30/24. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:49 P.M. with STNA #203 revealed Resident #77 did not report any concerns to her regarding the care or services she provided on 01/30/24. Interview on 02/06/24 at 2:34 P.M. with RN #205 revealed she received a call from Resident #77's friend on 01/31/24 in which the resident's friend told her Resident #77 said her arm was caught underneath her and rolled behind her during care prior day. RN #205 revealed she spoke to Resident #77 but did not specifically ask her about this incident. Interview on 02/07/24 at 8:56 A.M. with the Administrator revealed the facility was aware of Resident #77's friends' concern regarding potentially rough care for the resident on 01/30/24, but there was no investigation completed regarding the concern. Review of the facility policy titled Resident Abuse Prevention Practices dated October 2022 revealed the facilities' policy was to protect all residents from mistreatment, neglect, and abuse. This included protecting residents from any situation that would be harmful. Alleged suspected or observed abuse, neglect and mistreatment of a resident would be thoroughly investigated by the Administrator and the Director of Nursing (DON). Witness statements would be taken and interviews conducted with anyone involved or witnessing the incident. This deficiency represents noncompliance investigated under Complaint Number OH00150765.
366113
Page 5 of 9
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0677
Provide care and assistance to perform activities of daily living for any resident who is unable.
Level of Harm - Minimal harm or potential for actual harm
**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** Based on record review, interview, and facility policy review the facility failed to ensure residents received showers according to their preference. This affected three residents (#41, #70 and #77) of six residents reviewed for showers. This had the potential to affect all residents residing in the facility as the facility identified all residents require assistance with showers. The facility census was 97.
Residents Affected - Few
Findings include: 1. Review of the medical record for Resident #41 revealed an admission date of 03/11/20 with diagnoses including heart disease, left eye blindness, hyperlipidemia, stroke, and urinary retention. Review of the comprehensive Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #41 was cognitively intact. He required set up assistance for oral hygiene and personal hygiene and supervision for toileting, showering, and bathing. It was very important to him to choose between a tub bath, shower, bed bath, or a sponge bath. Review of the shower schedule revealed Resident #41 was supposed to receive a shower twice a week on Sundays and Wednesdays. Review of the state tested nurse aide (STNA) tasks dated 01/06/24 through 02/06/24 revealed Resident #41 had a shower on 01/09/24 and 01/17/24. Review of the shower sheets revealed Resident #41 had a shower on 12/06/23, 12/13/23, 12/20/23, 12/31/23, 01/01/24, 01/03/24, 01/09/24, 01/14/24, 01/16/24, 01/17/24, 01/29/24, and 02/04/24. The resident only received one shower a week in December 2023 and did not consistently receive two showers a week in January 2024. Interview on 02/06/24 at 8:40 A.M. with Resident #41 revealed he did not have a shower at all last week. 2. Review of the medical record for Resident #70 revealed an admission date of 01/17/23 with diagnoses including hypertension, hallucinations, muscle weakness, diabetes, and difficulty walking. Review of the quarterly MDS assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #70 was cognitively intact. He required partial moderate assistance for toileting, showering or bathing, set up help for oral hygiene, and supervision for personal hygiene. It was very important for him to choose between a tub bath, shower, bed bath, or sponge bath. Review of the shower schedule revealed Resident #70 was supposed to receive a shower twice a week on Mondays and Thursdays. Review of the STNA tasks dated 01/06/24 through 02/06/24 revealed Resident #70 had a shower on 01/09/24 and 01/29/24. There was no documented evidence of any additional showers. Interview on 02/06/24 at 8:42 A.M. with Resident #70 revealed he does not get showers twice a week like he wants. He was told by staff they would not be able to give him a shower this week.
366113
Page 6 of 9
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0677
Level of Harm - Minimal harm or potential for actual harm
Residents Affected - Few
3. Review of the medical record for Resident #76 revealed an admission date of 04/08/22 with diagnoses including stroke affecting the left non dominant side, narcolepsy, hypertension, anxiety, unspecified convulsions, and obesity. Review of the quarterly MDS assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #76 was cognitively intact. She required total dependence on staff for toileting, showering or bathing and partial to moderate assistance for oral and personal hygiene. It was very important to her to choose between a tub bath, shower, bed bath, or sponge bath. Review of the care plan dated 02/02/24 revealed Resident #76 had a behavior problem related to refusing care and stating it had not been provided. Interventions included anticipating the resident's needs, administering medications as ordered, praising progress or improvements in behavior, and monitoring behaviors to attempt to determine an underlying cause. Review of the shower schedule revealed Resident #76 was supposed to receive a shower twice a week on Sundays and Wednesdays. Review of the STNA tasks dated 01/06/24 through 02/06/24 revealed no evidence Resident #76 had a shower or refused at any time. Interview on 02/06/24 at 8:47 A.M. with STNA #201 revealed the facility had a hard time getting showers done and at times they could not be completed. Interview with the Administrator on 02/07/24 at 8:56 A.M. verified resident preferences for type and frequency of showers were assessed on admission. He confirmed no further information was available to confirm showers had been provided to Residents #41, #70 and #77. Review of the facility policy titled Bathing Preferences dated January 2023 revealed residents were interviewed during the admission process regarding the frequency and type of shower/bath as well as time of day preferred. Preferences would be reviewed quarterly and modified as needed. This deficiency is an incidental finding discovered during the complaint investigation.
366113
Page 7 of 9
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0689
Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.
Level of Harm - Actual harm
Residents Affected - Few
**NOTE- TERMS IN BRACKETS HAVE BEEN EDITED TO PROTECT CONFIDENTIALITY** Based on observation, record review, interview, and facility policy review the facility failed to ensure Resident #77 was free of an accident hazard during a staff assisted transfer. Actual Harm occurred on 01/30/24 when Resident #77 suffered a second-degree burn (a burn that involves the first two layers of skin which may present as deep reddening of the skin, pain, blisters, glossy appearance from leaking fluid, and possible loss of some skin) that measured 15 centimeters (cm) in length by 7.5 cm width to her left lower leg from a portable oxygen tank that had been placed on her bed while staff were transporting the resident from her room to the shower room. The improper transport of the oxygen caused the tank to freeze to the resident's leg causing pain/discomfort and the burn. The burn required treatment with Silvadene cream (medication used to help prevent and treat wound infections for serious burns) and Kerlix gauze to the area daily. This affected one resident (#77) of three residents reviewed for accidents. The facility census was 97.
Findings include: Review of the medical record for Resident #77 revealed an admission date of 04/07/23. Diagnoses included Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis (ALS) a progressive neurodegenerative disease that affects nerve cells in the brain and spinal cord, arthritis, depression, and hypertension. Review of the quarterly Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessment dated [DATE] revealed Resident #77 was cognitively intact. She required set up help for eating, oral hygiene, and personal hygiene, substantial or maximum assistance for showing or bathing, and was dependent on staff for toileting. Review of the progress note dated 01/30/24 at 3:03 P.M. revealed a State Tested Nursing Assistant (STNA) informed the nurse that another STNA mistakenly left Resident #77's portable oxygen lying on its side next to Resident #77's left lower leg. The resident obtained a burn that measured 15 centimeters (cm) in length by 7.5 cm in width. The resident reported some discomfort and was medicated with Tylenol (analgesic). The area was slightly pink with no open areas or drainage. The nurse aide supervisor was notified and educated staff on proper handling of portable oxygen tanks. The physician, power of attorney (POA), and clinical director were notified. Review of the facility incident report dated 01/30/24 at 4:08 P.M. revealed the oxygen tank was removed from Resident #77 after discovery of the injury. Two witnesses were noted to have been involved; however, there were no witness statements included on the investigation. Review of the physician's orders for February 2023 revealed an order to cleanse the left lower leg burn and apply Silvadene cream (medication used to help prevent and treat wound infections for serious burns) and Kerlix gauze to the left lower calf daily. Review of a facility provided document titled Wound Tracking Grid - Initial assessment dated 02/05/24 revealed the resident's calf wound measured 6.0 cm in length by 2.0 cm in width. The skin tone was normal with an intact scab. Interview on 02/06/24 at 10:28 A.M. with the Administrator revealed on 01/30/24 an oxygen tank was placed on the bed while Resident #77 was being transported to the shower. The oxygen tank collected
366113
Page 8 of 9
366113
02/08/2024
Liberty Health Care Center Inc
1355 Churchill Hubbard Rd Youngstown, OH 44505
F 0689
Level of Harm - Actual harm
ice and froze to the resident's leg. The Administrator reported the tank was immediately disconnected and staff were in-serviced on safe transport of portable oxygen. He confirmed there should have been a hook for caddy available for transporting the oxygen. The Administrator revealed the nurse assessed the injury, and the resident's mother was notified. STNA #203 did not sign the in-service sign in sheet.
Residents Affected - Few Interview on 02/06/24 at 10:51 A.M. with Resident #77 revealed she told STNA #203 her leg hurt while being transported to the shower, but STNA #203 told her they were almost there and did not stop to look at the source of the pain. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:40 P.M. with STNA #202 revealed on 01/30/24 STNA #203 placed the resident's oxygen tank on its side on the bed and it had ice on the outside. She confirmed oxygen should always be upright and never on its side. She revealed Resident #77 suffered a burn on her leg as a result of the oxygen tank touching her leg. Interview on 02/06/24 at 12:49 P.M. with STNA #203 revealed on 01/30/24 she was transporting Resident #77 to the shower and needed to take the resident's oxygen with her. She revealed the tank was hooked to the bed and stated she did not know it was touching her leg. She stated Resident #77 said her leg felt warm, but she did not see anything at the time. After the residents' shower she saw a burn on the resident's leg. She could not describe the size, shape, or color. She stated she let the nurse know immediately. Observation on 02/07/24 at 8:05 A.M. of wound care for Resident #77 revealed Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) #207 provided appropriate care and treatment to Resident #77's left lower leg. The wound was scabbed over with no odor or drainage observed. Interview at the time of the observation with both LPN #207 and the resident confirmed the wound looked better and was healing well. The resident denied any pain as of this time. Review of the in-service titled OSHA - Environmental Safety dated 07/01/23 revealed staff were educated prior to the incident on proper oxygen use including oxygen tanks were to be stored in a stand or cart to prevent tipping or falling, portable tanks were to be kept in an upright position, and any frosted parts or connections were not to be touched. STNA #203 did not sign the in-service sign in sheet (hire date was 03/14/23). Review of the facility policy titled Oxygen, liquid dated January 2023 revealed portable oxygen tanks were to be kept in an upright position and should be carried by a shoulder strap, hung on the back of a wheelchair, or placed in a wheeled cart. No frosted parts or connectors were to be touched. This deficiency represents noncompliance investigated under Complaint Number OH00150765.
366113
Page 9 of 9